Giuseppe Vizzari

Giuseppe Vizzari

Associate professor at University of Milano-Bicocca, Milan, Italy

The strange case of the emerging dead journal

2 minute read

Published:

If you have already read some of the posts in this blog you know my position on bibliometric forms of research evaluation. I promise this time I will be brief, but it’s a tasty bit, from my point of view.

Well, let’s start by a shameless plug on a past paper of mine that happens to appear in the inaugural issue of an open access journal for which I was a member of the editorial board. In retrospect, it was not necessarily a wise choice of venue for the paper: in Italy we now look at the quartile in a given subject area and category in which the journal is situated that year to determine the value of the published papers, so my paper was almost worthless from this perspective. On the other hand, the fact that it was open access made it easily accessible, so it attracted a good number of citations.

However, the journal was not very successful in attracting submissions (typical catch 22: it was not indexed so it did not attract many submissions, and it needed more published papers to be indexed), and it finally SpringerOpen decided to cease publishing it in late 2020.

The interesting thing is that for Scimago in 2023 it is (for the first time) a Q1 journal in one category for Computer Science and two categories in Mathematics!

A rare picture of Scimago and a friend keeping up a dead journal well high in the most appropriate quartile

Well, I can totally understand that an automatic process based on a simple ratio is prone to inertia, noise, potential manipulations, but we are talking about being in Q1 in three categories, not one, while last year it was in Q2 again for the same categories. The journal never made it to Q2 while it was being published, now it’s dead and emerging.

What is worse is again the overall system around this episode: I was looking at journals in Q1 and/or Q2 in specific categories of the Computer Science area, when I spotted this journal very high in the list. The simple fact that I was not looking at the journals most suited to my research but to those that are the best compromise between being right for my work and considered good enough from the research evaluation perspective is a rather depressing consideration on my own behavior.

You May Also Enjoy

Asking the right questions

6 minute read

Published:

The landscape of Italian journalism is quite depressing, from my point of view. I mostly listen to an independent local radio channel (Radio Popolare - by the way, they anticipated crowdfunding with a subscription mechanism although this subscription does not imply that they produce contents accessible only to subscribers, a curious and interesting approach) and read Internazionale, a magazine collecting and translating in Italian articles from International journals from all over the world. The last number of Internazionale proposed the translation in Italian of this article titled “AI Is a False God - The real threat with super intelligence is falling prey to the hype”, by Navneet Alang, from The Walrus, another editorial initiative that is worth following.

The irresistible growth of bureaucracy

2 minute read

Published:

Some bits and pieces that you can interpolate, and that - in my opinion - are part of a trajectory that you might see as well.

More tips to enlarge your H-index

4 minute read

Published:

In an earlier post I started talking about bibliometrics, some of its flaws, and what I think has become one of the facets of an ideology, something Jerry Z. Muller called “The tyranny of metrics”. I’m going to add two ways to enlarge your H-index that, at the same time, also represent a totally legitimate action in the overall context of a line research.

One of the problems with AI

3 minute read

Published:

You might know that I’m the coordinator of a master’s degree, in Italy. Ennio Flaiano, an Italian screenwriter, playwright, novelist, journalist, author of numerous enlightening aphorisms, said that:

In Italy the shortest line between two points is the arabesque